Written by Adv. Aman Chawla | Matrimonial Law Specialist | Delhi High Court & Supreme Court of India | 8 Years Exclusive Practice in Family & Matrimonial Law | Jangpura, New Delhi
The question of wife living in adultery maintenance often arises when a husband alleges that his wife is in an ongoing extramarital relationship and she files a maintenance case.
“Sir, my wife left me and is now living with another man. And she has filed for ₹60,000 a month maintenance from me. How is this fair?”
“Sir, my husband is accusing me of an affair only to avoid paying maintenance. I have done nothing wrong. Can he stop my maintenance just by saying this?”
I hear both sides of this question regularly. For husbands, it feels deeply unjust to pay a wife who is in a relationship with someone else. For wives, a false allegation of adultery is one of the most hurtful and humiliating weapons used in maintenance cases.
The law tries to balance both. It does take away maintenance from a wife who is “living in adultery”, but the bar for proving it is high, and a mere allegation is not enough. This article explains what the law says, what the Supreme Court decided in 2026, and how these cases actually play out in court.
Quick Answer
Under Section 144(4) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (old Section 125(4) CrPC), a wife is not entitled to maintenance or interim maintenance from her husband if she is “living in adultery”.
Courts have consistently read this to mean a continuing adulterous relationship, not a single lapse in the past. In Himanshu Chordia v. State of Rajasthan (Supreme Court, 2026), the Court considered when a husband’s adultery objection should affect interim and final maintenance. It held that interim maintenance can be denied at the outset only if the husband produces clear and cogent evidence that establishes adultery on the face of the record.
A bare allegation does not stop interim maintenance. A child’s right to maintenance is not affected by the mother’s conduct.
1. What Does the Law Say?
Section 144(4) BNSS says that no wife shall be entitled to receive maintenance or interim maintenance from her husband under this section if:
-
She is living in adultery, or
-
Without sufficient reason, she refuses to live with her husband, or
-
They are living separately by mutual consent.
Under Section 144(5), if the husband proves any of these after an order is passed, the Magistrate can cancel the order.
Note that since the Supreme Court decriminalised adultery in Joseph Shine v. Union of India (2018), adultery is no longer a crime. But it remains a ground for divorce under Section 13(1)(i) of the Hindu Marriage Act, and it remains relevant to maintenance.
For a broader explanation of the legal consequences, read our guide on cheating or adultery of wife under Indian law.
2. What Does “Living in Adultery” Mean?
This is where most husbands misunderstand the law.
“Living in adultery” does not mean that the wife once had an affair. It means a continuing course of adulterous conduct, such as living with another man or being in an ongoing relationship with him.
In Avadh Kishore Sah v. State of Bihar (Patna High Court, May 2025), the Court put it simply: living in adultery denotes a continuous course of conduct, not isolated acts of immorality. A few lapses followed by a return to normal life are not “living in adultery”.
The Court also noted that the husband had made only bald allegations, had not even pleaded adultery in his own divorce petition, and was willing to keep living with his wife, which contradicted his claim. The maintenance order was upheld.
Real-life example: Pankaj discovers chats showing that his wife Megha had a brief relationship with a colleague two years ago, before they moved to Delhi. They continued living together after that. When she later files for maintenance, Pankaj raises these old chats. This is unlikely to amount to “living in adultery”, because there is no continuing adulterous relationship at the time she claims maintenance.
Real-life example: Sunil’s wife left the matrimonial home in Rohini and, for the last eight months, has been living in a rented flat in Gurugram with another man. Neighbours, the rent agreement, joint photos and the society register all show this. This is a much stronger case of “living in adultery”, because it shows a continuing relationship.
3. The Supreme Court’s 2026 Ruling: Himanshu Chordia v. State of Rajasthan
In 2026, the Supreme Court (Justices Sanjay Karol and Vipul M. Pancholi, 2026 INSC 778) dealt with a case in which the husband had filed an application under Section 125(4) alleging adultery, along with a request for documents.
The trial court dismissed both and granted interim maintenance of ₹25,000 each to the wife and the child. The High Court said the adultery issue could be decided only at the final stage, after evidence.
The Supreme Court disagreed and sent the matter back. It held:
-
The adultery objection must be decided before final maintenance is adjudicated; postponing it would make the statutory bar meaningless.
-
Interim maintenance can be denied at the threshold only if the husband shows clear and cogent evidence that establishes adultery on the face of the record.
-
Merely filing an adultery application does not automatically stop interim maintenance. If the application later succeeds, the interim order can be vacated; if it fails, the interim order stands or is modified.
-
Electronic and circumstantial evidence, such as photographs and recordings, needs verification, and the wife has the right to dispute its correctness and legality.
-
The Court also expressed concern about the absence of any regulation of private investigators in India.
Read the full judgment: Himanshu Chordia v. State of Rajasthan – 2026 INSC 778.
In practical terms, this judgment helps both sides. A husband with strong, genuine evidence can now insist that the issue is decided early. A wife facing a false or weak allegation is protected, because interim maintenance cannot be stopped on a bare claim.
4. What Evidence Do Courts Look At?
Adultery is rarely proved by direct evidence. Courts look at the overall picture, usually through circumstantial evidence such as:
-
Proof of living together: Rent agreements, society records, utility bills and neighbours as witnesses.
-
Hotel records and travel bookings: Repeated stays together.
-
Photographs and videos: Properly proved.
-
Chats, emails and call records: With the required certificate for electronic evidence under the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023.
-
A child born from the relationship: In some cases.
A word of caution: obtain evidence lawfully. Hacking a phone, installing spyware or illegally accessing accounts can expose you to criminal liability and can weaken your case.
I have written separately on how WhatsApp chats can serve as evidence in matrimonial cases.
5. What If the Husband Is the One in an Affair?
The law works the other way too. Under the Explanation to Section 144(3) BNSS, if the husband has married another woman or keeps a mistress, the wife has a just ground to refuse to live with him, and she can still claim maintenance while living separately.
A husband’s adultery is also a ground for divorce for the wife, and courts take it into account in deciding alimony. I have explained a wife’s legal options in detail in my article on a husband’s affair and the wife’s legal options in India.
Real-life example: Ritu learns that her husband Aakash has been living with another woman in Noida for a year. She moves back to her parents’ home in Lajpat Nagar and files for maintenance. Aakash argues that she left him without reason. The court will see that his relationship with another woman gives her a sufficient reason to live separately, and her claim remains.
6. Does Adultery Affect Permanent Alimony?
Under Section 25(3) of the Hindu Marriage Act, a court that has granted permanent alimony may vary, modify or rescind the order if it is satisfied that the wife has not remained chaste (or, in the husband’s case, that he has had sexual intercourse with a woman outside wedlock).
Courts also consider the conduct of the parties while deciding the amount of alimony in the first place.
So adultery can affect alimony, but again, it has to be proved, not just alleged.
For more information, read our detailed guide on maintenance for wife in India and interim versus final maintenance in India.
7. What About the Children?
A child’s right to maintenance is independent of the mother’s conduct. Even if the wife is held to be living in adultery and her own maintenance is refused, the father remains liable to maintain the child.
In the Supreme Court case above, interim maintenance had been granted separately for the child as well.
8. Mistakes to Avoid
For husbands: alleging adultery without evidence. A false or reckless allegation of adultery can itself be treated as cruelty and can backfire badly.
For husbands: relying on an old, ended affair. The law looks at whether she is living in adultery, not whether she ever had a lapse.
For husbands: stopping payment on your own. If an interim order exists, pay it and apply to the court. Stopping payment invites recovery proceedings and warrants.
For wives: ignoring the allegation. Respond clearly and in time, and challenge any doubtful electronic evidence on its correctness and legality.
For both: illegal evidence gathering. Spyware and hacking can lead to criminal cases.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can a wife living in adultery claim maintenance in India?
A: No. Section 144(4) BNSS (old Section 125(4) CrPC) bars maintenance to a wife who is living in adultery. But “living in adultery” means a continuing relationship, and it must be proved.
Q: Can interim maintenance be stopped if the husband alleges adultery?
A: Only if he produces clear and cogent evidence that establishes adultery on the face of the record. A mere allegation is not enough (Himanshu Chordia v. State of Rajasthan, Supreme Court, 2026).
Q: Is a single affair enough to deny maintenance?
A: Generally no. Courts have held that isolated acts followed by a return to normal life are not “living in adultery”.
Q: Is adultery still a crime in India?
A: No. The Supreme Court decriminalised adultery in Joseph Shine v. Union of India (2018). It remains a ground for divorce and is relevant to maintenance.
Q: If my husband is in an affair, can I still claim maintenance?
A: Yes. If the husband keeps a mistress or has married another woman, the wife has a just ground to live separately and can claim maintenance.
Q: Does adultery affect child maintenance?
A: No. The child’s right to maintenance from the father is independent of the mother’s conduct.
Q: Can permanent alimony be cancelled because of adultery?
A: Under Section 25(3) HMA, the court may vary, modify or rescind alimony if the recipient spouse has not remained chaste, on proof.
Adv. Aman Chawla’s Practical Note
When a husband tells me his wife is living with another man, my first question is always: “What can you prove, and how did you get it?” A strong adultery objection is built on lawful, verifiable evidence of a continuing relationship, not on suspicion or anger.
And when a wife tells me her husband is accusing her falsely, I tell her not to panic. After the 2026 Supreme Court ruling, interim maintenance cannot be stopped on a bare allegation. Respond firmly, challenge the evidence, and let the court see the allegation for what it is.
Final Words
The law does not reward adultery, but it also does not allow the word “adultery” to be used as a shortcut to avoid paying maintenance. If there is a genuine, continuing adulterous relationship and you can prove it lawfully, the law protects you. If there is not, the law protects the wife. Either way, what decides the case is evidence, not allegations.
Consult Adv. Aman Chawla, Matrimonial Law Specialist, practicing before the Supreme Court of India, Delhi High Court, and all Delhi District Courts. Available for urgent matters, outstation clients, and online consultations across India.
Call: +91-8076836899 | WhatsApp | Email: info@thematrimoniallawyers.com
Office: O-11A Basement, Jangpura Extension, New Delhi – 110014
Written by Adv. Aman Chawla. This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is fact-specific. The examples in this article are illustrative and names and details have been changed or simplified. Please consult a qualified lawyer before taking any legal action.